For the price of one Shure SM58, you can get at least four Behringer XM8500 mics. Both are cardioid dynamic mics designed for vocals. In this article, we will compare Behringer XM8500 vs Shure SM58 to find out which model that will give the best value and performance for the money. Continue reading!
Our discussion below will tell you further about
– What’s included with each microphone here
– The comparison of their build quality
– The features of Behringer XM8500 and Shure SM58
– The sound quality of Behringer XM8500 vs Shure SM58
– Which microphone that is generally more recommended for you
Behringer XM8500: Overview
Despite being mainly designed for vocals, Behringer XM8500 is surprisingly versatile enough to fill other roles. It has been commonly used for drums and guitars in many home studios. Professionals often use this mic as a back-up mic or secondary mic, but many bands also use the mic as a primary mic due to its affordable and budget-friendly nature. See also: AKG D5 vs SM58.
Of course, the biggest advantage that Behringer XM8500 offers is its value per cost ratio. You can get it with a budget of less than twenty bucks. Despite the low price, it can deliver a very good performance.
There are only two possible issues with Behringer XM8500 vs Shure SM58. First, this mic does not have an on/off switch, so you will need to plug and unplug the cable manually in order to enable and disable the mic. Second, the mic is not the most durable unit in the world, so you will need to handle it with some care.
That being said, the mic does come with a nice-looking and durable cushioned case, which is very useful for safe storage and transport. The mic also comes with a mic clip, a stand adapter, and the product documentation. Unfortunately, the XLR cable must be purchased separately.
Behringer XM8500: Design and Features
Behringer XM8500 feels hefty and substantial with a weight of 8 ounces. Most of the weight comes from its metallic construction. You can hold it with one hand or two hands comfortably. The XLR connector is thick and reinforced with a gold plating. When you plug in an XLR cable, the connection will be secured by a solid click.
In terms of appearance, it is almost an imitation of Shure SM58, and this is not a bad thing at all. It has a classic appearance, and the simplistic design exudes attractiveness.
|Behringer XM8500||Shure SM58|
|Best Offer||click here||click here|
|Product Dimensions||2 x 2 x 0.6 inches||38.2 x 4.1 x 9.4 inches|
|Shipping Weight||1.43 pounds||9 pounds|
The symmetrical metal body is covered by a black anodized finish, which is really tough and resistant against scratches. The matte surface will provide a solid grip and secure handling. However, both the metal body and the anodized finish won’t protect the mic against heavy impacts.
Behringer XM8500 has some performance-enhancing features. It is equipped with an internal shock mount to suppress mechanical vibration and handling noise. In addition, it has a two-stage pop filter to eliminate wind and pop noises. The pop filter is very effective, especially on breathy singers.
The mic’s cardioid polar pattern is spot-on. When you get out from the pick-up angle, the amount of captured sound is reduced significantly. It also rejects ambient noise really well, making it a great choice for recording or performing in a loud area.
Behringer XM8500: Performance
If we compare the performance of Behringer XM8500 vs Shure SM58, they may sound quite similar. After all, they have a similar frequency response range of 50Hz – 15kHz. However, there are still subtle differences that set them apart.
Behringer XM8500 is able to capture all of the bulk of a human vocal spectrum. It is great for live performances, as it can reject background noise really well. It is also versatile enough to work on pretty much any instrument. The mic is especially great for rack toms and close-micing drums, though it is not really great for hi-hats and cymbals.
It can also work on a guitar amp quite well, though it will not be able to capture all of the vibrancy in the high-end. Compared to Shure SM58, Behringer XM8500 is noticeably more resistant against noise and feedback. You can pump up the gain without getting feedback issues, and you can position the mic with more flexibility.
Behringer XM8500 tends to sound a little bit hotter and louder than Shure SM58. This is a useful trait for vocals and instruments to help them soar above the mix.
If we observe the frequency response range of Behringer XM8500, there is a unique characteristic. While Shure SM58 provides a slight bump in the midrange, Behringer XM8500 offers the opposite. It has a slight scoop that spans from the mids to the high-mids. It also has a slight boost in the low-mids. As a result, Behringer XM8500 is particularly good for singers with somewhat reedy or nasally voices.
Shure SM58: Overview
Shure SM58 has built a solid reputation among musicians. It has all the traits that you want; it is durable, reliable, and affordable. Well, it is not as cheap as Behringer XM8500, but it is still considered a budget mic.
Many musicians have been using Shure SM58 mics for a long time, and they have given glowing positive reviews. There is very little that this mic can’t do. The mic is rugged and robust. It has a vocal-emphasized frequency response range that also works well on various instruments.
Shure SM58 is also loved by podcasters because of its presence boost on vocals and speeches. In addition, the cardioid polar pattern is quite effective for reducing ambient noise. A podcaster won’t need much effort to find a good placement for the mic.
However, the included accessories are quite sparse. You only get a stand adapter, which is fortunately of a high quality with a 180-degree swivel and a solid construction, and a zippered carrying pouch. Depending on the variant that you buy, the mic may not come with an XLR cable.
Shure SM58: Design and Features
In terms of appearance, Behringer XM8500 vs Shure SM58 look quite similar. The only notable difference is that Behringer XM8500 comes with a black grille, while Shure SM58 comes with a silver grille. Both mics look simple yet elegant.
The build quality of Shure SM58 is very good. The grille is removable to allow easy cleaning and replacement. Inside the grille, you can find a spherical pop filter that is very effective for reducing harsh fricatives and plosives. The mic is also equipped with an internal shock-mount for reducing vibration and handling noises. The metallic chassis feels very rugged and durable.
There are actually four different variants of Shure SM58. First, there is Shure SM58-LC which is without the cable. Second, there is Shure SM58-CN which includes an XLR cable. Then, there is Shure SM58-X2U which features an XLR-to-USB adapter. Finally, there is Shure SM58S which has an integrated on/off switch.
With these options, you should be able to find one that suits your needs best. The variant that has an on/off switch is particularly attractive, as it will allow much easier control over the mic. The on/off switch is magnetic, and you can move the switch silently without creating a noise that may get picked up.
Shure SM58: Performance
Shure SM58 has been touted as one of the best microphones in the low-end price range. It has a frequency response range of 50Hz – 15kHz, which is suitable for highlighting vocals. It features a sloping bass attenuation for frequencies under 100Hz, and this is useful for minimizing the proximity effect. The reduced bass presence will also allow easier editing in post-production.
As mentioned above, Shure SM58 has a slight bump in the mids and high-mids. This makes it great for vocals as well as acoustic guitars. However, Shure SM58 is not recommended for low-frequency instruments such as bass guitars and kick drums.
This is due to the bass attenuation in the frequency response. If you try to use the mic on a bass guitar and then compare it to an acoustic guitar, you will notice that the sound is relatively quieter.
Because of that, Shure SM58 is somewhat less versatile than Behringer XM8500. This is not to say that Shure SM58 is a bad mic. This simply means that Shure SM58 is best for vocals and certain instruments.
Another thing to note about Shure SM58 is that, while it is generally a good mic for both studio use and live performance, it seems to be more prone to feedback issues compared to Behringer XM8500. So, you need to be more careful with the mic’s placement. That being said, Shure SM58’s reduced proximity effect is still a useful benefit in live situations.
Behringer XM8500 vs Shure SM58
If you have a very limited budget, Behringer XM8500 is generally more recommended. This is a very good mic with an unbeatable value. It has good overall performance, and is suitable for vocals and many instruments. The sound is slightly hotter and louder. Meanwhile, Shure SM58 is great for live vocals if you don’t mind spending a little bit more money.